Detection Probability and Site Occupancy of the Granular Spiny Frog (Quasipaa verrucospinosa) in the Tropical Rain Forests of Bach Ma National Park, Central Vietnam

Binh Van Ngo, Ya-Fu Lee, Chung D. Ngo


Amphibian species are rarely detected with perfect accuracy, regardless of the method employed. A large-scale assessment for Quasipaa verrucospinosa occupancy was conducted at 35 sites in the primary forest and 42 sites in the secondary forest of Bach Ma National Park, central Vietnam. Based on the detection data for each site, the distribution of Q. verrucospinosa was estimated in different habitat types using occupancy models. From the best model among all performed models, we estimated a site occupancy probability of 0.576 that was higher than the naive occupancy estimate of 0.403 and a 43.1% increase over the site proportion at which Q. verrucospinosa was actually observed. The site covariate of the primary forest was an important determinant of site occupancy, which was not associated with the variable of secondary forest. In a combined AIC model weight: the p(temperature), p(humidity), and p(precipitation) models have 47.3, 67.1, and 90.9% of the total, respectively; providing evidence that aforementioned environmental conditions were important sample covariates in modelling detection probabilities of Q. verrucospinosa. Our results substantiate the importance of incorporating detection and occupancy probabilities into studies of habitat relationships and suggest that the primary forests associated with weather conditions influence the site occupancy of Q. verrucospinosa in Bach Ma National Park, central Vietnam.


detection probability; maximum likelihood; metapopulation; site occupancy; Quasipaa verrucospinosa; rainforests; Vietnam

Full Text:



Bailey L. L., Hines J. E., Nichols J. D., and MacKenzie D. I. (2007), «Sampling design trade-offs in occupancy studies with imperfect detection: examples and software», Ecol. Appl., 17(1), 281 – 290.

Bailey L. L., Simons T. R., and Pollock K. H. (2004), «Estimating site occupancy and species detection probability parameters for terrestrial salamanders», Ecol. Appl., 14(3), 692 – 702.

Bisrat S. A., White M. A., Beard K. H., and Richard Cutler D. (2012), «Predicting the distribution potential of an invasive frog using remotely sensed data in Hawaii», Divers. Distr., 18(7), 648 – 660.

Burnham K. P. and Anderson D. R. (2002), Model Selection and Inference: A Practical Information-Theoretic Approach, Springer-Verlag, New York.

Carey C., Heyer W. R., Wilkinson J., Alford R. A., Arntzen J. W., Halliday T., et al. (2001), «Amphibian declines and environmental change: use of remote-sensing data to identify environmental correlates», Conserv. Biol., 15(4), 903 – 913.

Demaynadier P. G. and Hunter M. L. (1999), «Forest canopy closure and juvenile emigration by pool-breeding amphibians in Maine», J. Wildlife Manag., 63(2), 441 – 450.

Dorazio R. M., Royle J. A., Söderström B., and Glimskär A. (2006), «Estimating species richness and accumulation by modelling species occurrence and detectability», Ecology, 87(4), 842 – 854.

Gu W. and Swihart R. K. (2004), «Absent or undetected? Effects of non-detection of species occurrence on wildlife habitat models», Biol. Conserv., 116(2), 195 – 203.

Hanski I. (1994), «A practical model of metapopulation dynamics», J. Animal Ecol., 63(1), 151 – 162.

Hoang Q. X., Hoang T. N., and Ngo C. D. (2012), Amphibians and Reptiles in Bach Ma National Park, Agricultural Publishing House, Hanoi, Vietnam.

Kaiser K. (2008), «Evaluation of a long-term amphibian monitoring protocol in central America», J. Herpetol., 42(1), 104 – 110.

Lehtinen R. M. and Galatowitsch S. M. (2001), «Colonization of restored wetlands by amphibians in Minnesota», Am. Midland Naturalist, 145(2), 388 – 396.

MacKenzie D. I., Bailey L. L., and Nichols J. D. (2004), «Investigating species co-occurrence patterns when species are detected imperfectly», J. Animal Ecol., 73(3), 546 – 555.

MacKenzie D. I., Nichols J. D., Hines J. E., Knutson M. G., and Franklin A. B. (2003), «Estimating site occupancy, colonization, and local extinction when a species is detected imperfectly», Ecology, 84(8), 2200 – 2207.

MacKenzie D. I., Nichols J. D., Lachman G. B., Droege S., Royle J. A., and Langtimm C. A. (2002), «Estimating site occupancy rates when detection probabilities are less than one», Ecology, 83(8), 2248 – 2255.

MacKenzie D. I., Nichols, J. D., Royle J. A., Pollock K. H., Bailey L. L., and Hines J. E. (2006), Occupancy Estimation and Modelling: Inferring Patterns and Dynamics of Species Occurrence, Acad. Press, New York.

Mazerolle M. J. (2006), «Improving data analysis in herpetology: using Akaike’s information criterion (AIC) to assess the strength of biological hypotheses», Amphibia–Reptilia, 27(2), 169 – 180.

Moilanen A. (1999), «Patch occupancy models of metapopulation dynamics: efficient parameter estimation using implicit statistical inference», Ecology, 80(3), 1031 – 1043.

Ngo B. V. (2015), Amphibian Diversity in Central Vietnam and the Distribution Pattern and Natural History of Granular Spiny Frogs Quasipaa verrucospinosa (Anura: Dicroglossidae). Ph.D. Dissertation, National Cheng Kung University, Taiwan.

Ngo B. V., Lee Y. F., and Ngo C. D. (2014), «Variation in dietary composition of granular spiny frogs (Quasipaa verrucospinosa) in central Vietnam», Herpetol. J., 24(4), 245 – 253.

Ngo B. V., Ngo C. D., and Hou P. C. L. (2013), «Reproductive ecology of Quasipaa verrucospinosa (Bourret, 1937): living in the tropical rain forests of central Vietnam», J. Herpetol., 47(1), 138 – 147.

Nguyen V. C., Ngo H., Le T. L., and Phan N. T. (2013), Thua Thien Hue Monographs, Social Sciences Publishing House, Hanoi, Vietnam.

Nguyen V., Truong D. H., Hoang T. L., Nguyen V. H., Phung D. V., and Ha H. K. (2004), Climatic-hydrology Characters of Thua Thien Hue Province, Thuan Hoa Publishing House, Hue, Vietnam.

Nichols J. D., Hines J. E., MacKenzie D. I., Seamans M. E., and Gutierrez R. J. (2007), «Occupancy estimation and modelling with multiple states and state uncertainty», Ecology, 88(6), 1395 – 1400.

O’Connell A. F., Talancy N. W., Bailey L. L., Sauer J. R., Cook R., and Gilbert A. T. (2006), «Estimating site occupancy and detection probability parameters for meso- and large mammals in a coastal ecosystem», J. Wildlife Manag., 70(6), 1625 – 1633.

Pollock K. H., Nichols J. D., Simons T. R., Farnsworth G. L., Bailey L. L., and Sauer J. R. (2002), «Large scale wildlife monitoring studies: statistical methods for design and analysis», Environmetrics, 13(2), 105 – 119.

Porej D., Micacchion M., and Hetherington T. E. (2004), «Core terrestrial habitat for conservation of local populations of salamanders and wood frogs in agricultural landscapes», Biol. Conserv., 120(3), 399 – 409.

Price S. J., Marks D. R., Howe R. W., Hanowski J. M., and Niemi G. J. (2004), «The importance of spatial scale for conservation and assessment of anuran populations in coastal wetlands of the western Great Lakes, USA», Landscape Ecol., 20(4), 441 – 454.

Reilly S. M., Mcbrayer L. D., and Miles D. B. (2007), Lizard Ecology, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge.

Rothermel B. B. and Semlitsch R. D. (2002), «An experimental investigation of landscape resistance of forests versus old-field habitats to emigrating juvenile amphibians», Conserv. Biol., 16(5), 1324 – 1332.

Seber G. A. F. (1982), The Estimation of Animal Abundance and Related Parameters, MacMillan Press, New York.

Shive J. P., Pilliod D. S., and Peterson C. R. (2010), «Hyperspectral analysis of Columbia spotted frog habitat», J. Wildlife Manag., 74(6), 1387 – 1394.

Skelly D. K., Werner E. E., and Cortwright S. A. (1999), «Long-term distributional dynamics of a Michigan amphibian assemblage», Ecology, 80(7), 2326 – 2337.

Skelly D. K., Yurewicz K. L., Werner E. E., and Relyea R. A. (2003), «Estimating decline and distributional change in amphibians», Conserv. Biol., 17(3), 744 – 751.

Thompson S. K. (1992), Sampling, John Wiley, New York.

Tyre A. J., Tenhumberg B., Field S. A., Niejalke D., Parris K., and Possingham H. P. (2003), «Improving precision and reducing bias in biological surveys: estimating false-negative error rates», Ecol. Appl., 13(6), 1790 – 1801.

van Dijk P. P. and Swan S. (2004), «Quasipaa verrucospinosa», The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species, 2004, e.T58442A11781714. Downloaded on 20 September 2018.

Vitt L. J. and Caldwell J. P. (2009), Herpetology, Acad. Press, Massachusetts.

Weir L. A., Royle J. A., Nanjappa P., and Jung R. E. (2005), «Modelling anuran detection and site occupancy on North American amphibian monitoring program (NAAMP) routes in Maryland», J. Herpetol., 39(4), 627 – 639.

Weyrauch S. L. and Grubb T. C. (2004), «Patch and landscape characteristics associated with the distribution of woodland amphibians in an agricultural fragmented landscape: an information-theoretic approach», Biol. Conserv., 115(3), 443 – 450.

Williams B. K., Nichols J. D., and Conroy M. J. (2002), Analysis and Management of Animal Populations, Acad. Press, California.

Yoccoz N. G., Nichols J. D., and Boulinier T. (2001), «Monitoring of biological diversity in space and time; concepts, methods and designs», Trends Ecol. Evol., 16(8), 446 – 453.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

You can subscribe to the print or electronic version of the journal on the site of EastView Company. If you have any questions, please write to the email